Portal de investigación
Effects of targeting lower versus higher arterial oxygen saturations on death or disability in preterm infants
Fecha de publicación:
Autores de IIS La Fe
Participantes ajenos a IIS La Fe
- Askie, LM
- Darlow, BA
- Davis, PG
- Finer, N
- Stenson, B
- Whyte, R
Grupos
Abstract
Background The use of supplemental oxygen in the care of extremely preterm infants has been common practice since the 1940s. Despite this, there is little agreement regarding which oxygen saturation (SpO) ranges to target to maximise short- or long-term growth and development, while minimising harms. There are two opposing concerns. Lower oxygen levels (targeting SpO at 90% or less) may impair neurodevelopment or result in death. Higher oxygen levels (targeting SpO greater than 90%) may increase severe retinopathy of prematurity or chronic lung disease. The use of pulse oximetry to non-invasively assess neonatal SpO levels has been widespread since the 1990s. Until recently there were no randomised controlled trials (RCTs) that had assessed whether it is better to target higher or lower oxygen saturation levels in extremely preterm infants, from birth or soon thereafter. As a result, there is significant international practice variation and uncertainty remains as to the most appropriate range to target oxygen saturation levels in preterm and low birth weight infants. Objectives 1. What are the effects of targeting lower versus higher oxygen saturation ranges on death or major neonatal and infant morbidities, or both, in extremely preterm infants? 2. Do these effects differ in different types of infants, including those born at a very early gestational age, or in those who are outborn, without antenatal corticosteroid coverage, of male sex, small for gestational age or of multiple birth, or by mode of delivery? Search methods We used the standard search strategy of Cochrane Neonatal to search the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL 2016, Issue 4), MEDLINE via PubMed (1966 to 11 April 2016), Embase (1980 to 11 April 2016) and CINAHL (1982 to 11 April 2016). We also searched clinical trials databases, conference proceedings and the reference lists of retrieved articles for randomised controlled trials. Selection criteria Randomised controlled trials that enrolled babies born at less than 28 weeks' gestation, at birth or soon thereafter, and targeted SpO ranges of either 90% or below or above 90% via pulse oximetry, with the intention of maintaining such targets for at least the first two weeks of life. Data collection and analysis We used the standard methods of Cochrane Neonatal to extract data from the published reports of the included studies. We sought some additional aggregate data from the original investigators in order to align the definitions of two key outcomes. We conducted the meta-analyses with Review Manager 5 software, using the Mantel-Haenszel method for estimates of typical risk ratio (RR) and risk difference (RD) and a fixed-effect model. We assessed the included studies using the Cochrane 'Risk of bias' and GRADE criteria in order to establish the quality of the evidence. We investigated heterogeneity of effects via pre-specified subgroup and sensitivity analyses. Main results Five trials, which together enrolled 4965 infants, were eligible for inclusion. The investigators of these five trials had prospectively planned to combine their data as part of the NeOProM (Neonatal Oxygen Prospective Meta-analysis) Collaboration. We graded the quality of evidence as high for the key outcomes of death, major disability, the composite of death or major disability, and necrotising enterocolitis; and as moderate for blindness and retinopathy of prematurity requiring treatment. When an aligned definition of major disability was used, there was no significant difference in the composite primary outcome of death or major disability in extremely preterm infants when targeting a lower (SpO(2) 85% to 89%) versus a higher (SpO(2) 91% to 95%) oxygen saturation range (typical RR 1.04, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.98 to 1.10; typical RD 0.02, 95% CI-0.01 to 0.05; 5 trials, 4754 infants) (high-quality evidence). Compared with a higher target range, a lower target range significantly increased the incidence of death at 18 to 24 months corrected age (typical RR 1.16, 95% CI 1.03 to 1.31; typical RD 0.03, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.05; 5 trials, 4873 infants) (high-quality evidence) and necrotising enterocolitis (typical RR 1.24, 95% 1.05 to 1.47; typical RD 0.02, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.04; 5 trials, 4929 infants; I-2 = 0%) (high-quality evidence). Targeting the lower range significantly decreased the incidence of retinopathy of prematurity requiring treatment (typical RR 0.72, 95% CI 0.61 to 0.85; typical RD-0.04, 95% CI-0.06 to-0.02; 5 trials, 4089 infants; I-2 = 69%) (moderate-quality evidence). There were no significant differences between the two treatment groups for major disability including blindness, severe hearing loss, cerebral palsy, or other important neonatal morbidities. A subgroup analysis of major outcomes by type of oximeter calibration software (original versus revised) found a significant difference in the treatment effect between the two software types for death (interaction P = 0.03), with a significantly larger treatment effect seen for those infants using the revised algorithm (typical RR 1.38, 95% CI 1.13 to 1.68; typical RD 0.06, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.10; 3 trials, 1716 infants). There were no other important differences in treatment effect shown by the subgroup analyses using the currently available data. Authors' conclusions In extremely preterm infants, targeting lower (85% to 89%) SpO(2) compared to higher (91% to 95%) SpO(2) had no significant effect on the composite outcome of death or major disability or on major disability alone, including blindness, but increased the average risk of mortality by 28 per 1000 infants treated. The trade-offs between the benefits and harms of the different oxygen saturation target ranges may need to be assessed within local settings (e.g. alarm limit settings, staffing, baseline outcome risks) when deciding on oxygen saturation targeting policies.
Datos de la publicación
- ISSN/ISSNe:
- 1469-493X, 1469-493X
- Tipo:
- Review
- Páginas:
- -
- Factor de Impacto:
- 2,347 SCImago ℠
- Cuartil:
- Q1 SCImago ℠
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS WILEY
Citas Recibidas en Web of Science: 117
Documentos
- No hay documentos
Filiaciones
Keywords
- LOW-BIRTH-WEIGHT; PREVENTING RETROLENTAL FIBROPLASIA; RESPIRATORY-DISTRESS-SYNDROME; CHRONIC LUNG-DISEASE; 28 WEEKS GESTATION; SUPPLEMENTAL OXYGEN; SEVERE RETINOPATHY; PREMATURE-INFANTS; PULSE OXIMETRY; OUTCOMES
Proyectos asociados
RED DE SALUD MATERNO-INFANTIL Y DEL DESARROLLO
RD08/0072/0022 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2008
RED DE BIOBANCOS (BIOBANCOS)
RD09/0076/00021 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2010
INMADUREZ HEPATICA Y VARIABILIDAD DE LA RESPUESTA AL IBUPROFENO EN EL DUCTUS ARTERIOSO PERSISTENTE (DAP) DEL PREMATURO. ESTUDIO DE LA ACTIVIDAD CYP-450 EN PREMATUROS.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
AP-203/10 . 2010
REPERCUSIONES DE LOS PROCEDIMIENTOS DOLOROSOS DE ENFERMERIA SOBRE LA ESTABILIDAD DEL PREMATURO EN UNA UCIN EN FUNCION DEL CICLO DE SUEÑO
Investigador Principal: PILAR SÁENZ GONZÁLEZ
EV.TEC: 016/2010 . 2010
ALTERACIONES METABONOMICAS EN EL PREMATURO EXTREMO DEPENDIENTES DE LA CARGA DE OXIGENO RECIBIDA EN LA REANIMACION POSTNATAL: UN ESTUDIO PROSPECTIVO ALEATORIZADO.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
PI11/00313 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III . 2012
UTILIDAD DEL TRATAMIENTO TOCOLITICO DE MANTENIMIENTO EN EL MANEJO DE LA AMENAZA DE PARTO PREMATURO (APP)
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
EC11-246 . 2012
MULTICENTER, RANDOMIZED, BLINDED CLINICAL STUDY COMPARING EARLY USE OF TOTAL BODY MODERATE HYPOTHERMIA PLUS TOPIRAMATE OR PLACEBO IN ASPHYXIATED NEWBORN INFANTS EVOLVING TO MODERATE-TO-SEVERE HYPOXIC ISCHEMIC ENCEPHALOPATHY
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
EC11-244 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2012
AYUDA PREDOCTORAL DE FORMACION EN INVESTIGACION
FI12/00109 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2012
RED DE SALUD MATERNO INFANTIL Y DEL DESARROLLO
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
RD12/0026/0012 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2013
CONTRATO POST FSE (RIO HORTEGA)
CM12/00187 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2013
CONTRATO POSTDOCTORAL DE INVESTIGACION SARA BORELL
CD12/00667 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2013
BIOMARCADORES DEL ESTRÉS OXIDATIVO Y LA REGULACIÓN REDOX COMO INDICADORES DEL DESARROLLO NEUROLÓGICO EN RECIÉN NACIDOS PREMATUROS REANIMADOS CON DIFERENTES CONCENTRACIONES DE OXÍGENO AL NACER
2013_0282_CRC_SERVERO_OCHOA_CHAFER . AYUNTAMIENTO DE VALENCIA . 2014
DAÑO OXIDATIVO Y METILACIÓN DEL ADN Y ACTIVIDAD DE LAS ENZIMAS REPARADORAS Y SU FRECUENCIA MUTAGÉNICA EN PREMATUROS SEGÚN LA CARGA DE OXÍGENO RECIBIDA EN LA REANIMACIÓN
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
PI14/00443 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III . 2015
CONTRATO POST FSE (RIO HORTEGA)
CM14/00012 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2015
ALBINO. EFFECT OF ALLOPURINOL IN ADDITION TO HYPOTHERMIA FOR HYPOXIC-ISCHEMIC BRAIN INJURY ON NEUROCOGNITIVE OUTCOME.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
667224 . COMISION EUROPEA . 2016
ADOPTIVE IMMUNOTHERAPY WITH CYTOTOXIC T LYMPHOCYTES AGAINST SPECIFIC VIRUSES AND TUMORAL ANTIGENS AFTER UNRELATED DONOR UMBILICAL CORD BLOOD TRANSPLANTATION.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
2016_0106_CRC_SANZ-DKMS . LABORATORIOS ORDESA S.L . 2016
CONTRATO POST FSE (RIO HORTEGA) Ana Alejandra García Robles
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
CM16/00174 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2017
CONTRATO PFIS: PREDOCTORALES DE FORMACION EN INVESTIGACION EN SALUD.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
FI16/00380 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III; FUNDACIÓN PARA LA INVESTIGACIÓN DEL HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO LA FE DE LA COMUNIDAD VALENCIANA . 2017
RED DE SALUD MATERNO-INFANTIL Y DEL DESARROLLO.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
RD16/0022/0001 . INSTITUTO DE SALUD CARLOS III . 2017
ENSAYO CLÍNICO MULTICÉNTRICO, ALEATORIZADO, DOBLE CIEGO Y CONTROLADO POR PLACEBO, COMPARANDO EL USO DE LA HIPOTERMIA CORPORAL TOTAL MODERADA PRECOZ CON TOPIRAMATO O CON PLACEBO EN RECIÉN NACIDOS ASFIXIADOS EVOLUCIONANDO A ENCEFALOPATÍA HIPÓXICO ISQUÉMICA MODERADA A SEVERA.
Investigador Principal: MÁXIMO VENTO TORRES
1645-CI-058 (HYPOTOP) . 2013
Cita
Askie LM,Darlow BA,Davis PG,Finer N,Stenson B,Vento M,Whyte R. Effects of targeting lower versus higher arterial oxygen saturations on death or disability in preterm infants. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2017. 4(4):CD011190. IF:6,754. (1).